Former NPRA CEO Criticizes Timing and Engagement in Ghana’s Domestic Debt Exchange Program

Raphael Nii Trebi Hammond
Former Chief Executive Officer of the National Pensions Regulatory Authority (NPRA) Mr. Atta Krufi has criticized government’s approach to the Domestic Debt Exchange Programme (DDEP), highlighting inadequate stakeholder engagement and poor timing as key factors that exacerbated its impact. Speaking on Business Breakfast on ZED, Mr. Krufi contrasted Ghana’s strategy with Jamaica’s more successful debt restructuring efforts, emphasizing the need for thorough preparation and communication. “It wasn’t something that the government had really thought through like it happened in Jamaica. Jamaica’s one, the stakeholder engagement was for a long time before it finally hit. So people had been prepared,” Mr. Krufi remarked. He pointed out that Ghana’s approach was abrupt, leading to confusion and panic among stakeholders. “Ghana’s one was quite a sharp shock and awe. People could not get enough time to really fully understand,” he added. In Jamaica, extensive stakeholder engagement preceded the debt restructuring, allowing for better preparation and understanding among the populace. This methodical approach contributed to Jamaica’s remarkable debt reduction journey over the past decade, reducing its debt-to-GDP ratio by almost half following decades of economic challenges.
In contrast, Ghana’s DDEP was introduced swiftly, causing uncertainty among bondholders and pension contributors. Mr. Krufi noted that while no one was set to lose their investments outright, the sudden announcement of postponed payments led to widespread panic. “The fact that suddenly we’re talking about it that, oh, we’re not gonna pay it when it is due, and that we are going to exchange it for something, and then we are going to postpone the payment. That was where the panic came from,” he explained.
The timing of the DDEP coincided with the maturation of Tier Three pension schemes, which began around 2011 and 2012. By 2022 and 2023, contributors were expecting to access their funds. However, with trust companies having invested these monies into the bond market, the sudden restructuring meant they couldn’t retrieve the funds as anticipated, leading to potential runs on pension companies. “People needed money. For example, those who had done what we call the voluntary contributions, the Tier Three as it is properly known… by the year 2022 and 2023, we were hitting the ten-year period that people needed their money back,” Mr. Krufi elaborated.
He further highlighted that the DDEP’s implementation came at a time when the nation was recovering from the COVID-19 pandemic and grappling with a cost-of-living crisis, making the abrupt introduction of the program particularly detrimental. “It wasn’t the best in terms of timing of the whole program, and that is why the effect seemed quite catastrophic, and we never ever recovered,” he lamented. Mr. Krufi’s insights underscore the critical importance of comprehensive stakeholder engagement and strategic timing in implementing economic reforms. Drawing lessons from Jamaica’s experience, he advocates for a more deliberate and inclusive approach to policy changes to mitigate adverse effects on citizens and institutions.



