Listen to great music on ZED 101.9FM

Listen Now

IEA calls for independent Fiscal Council

The Institute of Economic Affairs (IEA) is advocating for an urgent return to stringent fiscal rules and the establishment of an independent Fiscal Council (FC) to entrench fiscal responsibility and avoid recurring reliance on International Monetary Fund (IMF) support.

The IEA recommends that the Fiscal Council be established through a competitive process by the Public Services Commission and approved by Parliament to ensure its independence from the Executive. The Council’s budget should be directly appropriated by Parliament and charged to the Consolidated Fund.

Dr. J. K. Kwakye, Director of Research at the IEA, stated that the closest Ghana has come to adopting fiscal rules was the option given to the Minister of Finance under the Public Financial Management Act (PFMA) to propose specific numerical fiscal rules and the imposition of a 5% ceiling on the fiscal deficit under the Fiscal Responsibility Act (FRA).

However, Dr. Kwakye noted that the Fiscal Policy Advisory Council (FPAC) established by the President lacks true independence. “The establishment of a new Fiscal Council should comprise independent experts who are adequately resourced and tasked with responsibilities including analyzing government budgets, providing independent budget forecasts, assessing budgetary outcomes and risks, and monitoring fiscal rules,” he said.

Dr. Kwakye explained that while the FRA’s deficit ceiling could be seen as the Minister’s response to the PFMA requirement, it operated only for 2018-19. In 2020, the Minister suspended it, citing COVID-19 to invoke the “Escape Clause Mechanism” in the FRA. This suspension resulted in a deficit of over 15% in 2020 and eventually led the country back to the IMF for a bailout, supported by an Extended Credit Facility (ECF) program spanning 2023 to 2026.

“Obviously, we cannot continue to do the same things and expect different results. Many prudently managed economies operate within rules that limit fiscal policy discretion and arbitrariness. The rules provide the needed anchor regarding fiscal and debt sustainability,” Dr. Kwakye emphasized.

He identified another major lapse in Ghana’s fiscal policy as the lack of a strong analytical framework and an effective monitoring and oversight mechanism. As a result, fiscal policy appears to be formulated more or less on an ad-hoc basis, unsupported by a well-grounded framework tailored to safeguarding macroeconomic stability and fiscal and debt sustainability.

Furthermore, Dr. Kwakye pointed out that Parliament often lacks the time and requisite expertise to conduct thorough and effective analysis and oversight of the budget, allowing deficiencies, inefficiencies, and often corrupt practices to prevail. “In some instances, Parliament usually fails to enforce its own Appropriations Bill that approves annual government spending, allowing overruns to occur incessantly and with impunity,” he noted.

To address these issues, the IEA recommends more stringent fiscal rules, such as capping the country’s overall deficit ceiling at 3% of GDP, aligning with ECOWAS standards, and maintaining a public debt ceiling of 60% of GDP, deemed sustainable for middle-income countries like Ghana.

“We would recommend the more stringent ECOWAS ceiling of 3% for Ghana, which has a greater chance of delivering debt sustainability than the current 5% in the FRA. But even to buttress the deficit rule, we would propose two additional rules—a debt rule and a borrowing-investment rule. The debt rule should cap the debt/GDP at 60%, deemed a sustainable threshold for middle-income countries, such as Ghana. The cap should apply on a continuous basis,” Dr. Kwakye said.

Additionally, the IEA recommends that borrowing be used solely for investment in productive projects to ensure economic growth and future repayment capability.

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *