New tool for assessing government welfare and fiscal interventions launched

By Selorm GBORBIDZI, Accra
A new tool for assessing the effectiveness of government’s fiscal policy has been launched by the World Bank, in partnership with the Institute for Social Statistical and Economic Research (ISSER) and Oxfam in Ghana.
The micro-simulation tool, GHASIM, used data from the 2017 Ghana Living Standards Survey 2017 (GLSS 7) to determine the effectiveness of government’s policies, especially it’s social intervention policies like the Livelihood Empowerment Against Poverty (LEAP) programme and the Free Senior High School (SHS) policy in reducing inequality and the poverty gap.
The tool found that many of the government’s policies which were assessed were retrogressive in nature.
Presenting the results of their findings Director of Research at the International Centre for Evaluation and Development (ICED), Kwadwo Danso-Mensah , said that there’s a declining rate in the reduction of poverty while inequality seems to be on the ascendency.
The researchers found that higher poverty rates were occasioned mainly by indirect taxes.
Comparing the current data to those from previous studies, the researchers observed that the LEAP for instance has “significantly improved on its coverage in recent years, and it is important for government to resolve the perennial challenge of late payments to caterers.”
GHASIM also found that the current tax income tax system (Pay As You Earn) is highly progressive. This is also the case with the self-employed in both formal and informal sectors.
Furthermore, the tool discovered that subsidies on electricity are regressive. Although there is a tiered electricity tariff structure intended to offer higher subsidies to the poor and vulnerable, they have a positive concentration coefficient.
What the researchers concluded was that many poor households live in shared compound houses where occupants share electricity meters. This leads to aggregated consumption which will take them above the lifeline band, though they fall within this band individually.
They also discovered that excessive taxes are progressive, particularly those being levied on petroleum products (diesel and petrol), beverages like beer and malt drinks and telecommunications services.
Kwadwo Danso-Mensah also indicated that in and out-patient health expenditures were quite equitable.
In the area of education, they found that public expenditure at the pre-SHS levels are progressive while expenditure at the SHS level is relatively less progressive.
They attributed this pre-SHS progressiveness to the high patronage of private basic schools by richer households.
Danso-Mensah stated that the simulation had showed that that in the short term (without incorporating any behavioural response to the policy) poverty rates hadd reduced marginally – by 0.07 percentage points and 0.22 percentage points at the national lower and upper poverty lines.
On the water and electricity subsidies provided during the COVID-19 pandemic, the researchers on the assumption that the subsidies only went those households with piped water and electricity, concluded that these subsidies reduced headcount poverty,.
However, the water subsidy led to an increase in inequality while the electricity subsidy reduced inequality only marginally, “leaving the net effect to be nearly neutral.”
They attributed the increase in water inequality to the lack of targeting.
Kwadwo Danso-Mensah said, “in terms of progressivitiy, not much seems to have been achieved: the COVID-19 electricity and water interventions were not progressive, with that of water being less regressive.”
This seems to corroborate the idea that the rich tend to have higher access to basic household utilities which allow them to benefit more from subsidies.”
They therefore recommended that government revise the tariff structure based on comprehensive profiling of consumers.
They also suggested that electricity meters be made available to individual households ensure greater welfare redistribution through subsidies.
Government they further suggested should increase the pace of the rural electrification project to ensure greater access for poor households in rural communities.
The researchers suggested that government expand its social intervention programmes to cover more beneficiaries.
They also want government to continue with the subsidies and expenditure on basic education while ensuring improved service provision at all levels.
They also want expenditure on educational levels beyond basic education to be properly targeted.
Beyond this, they urged government to incorporate a targeting framework in the provision of social services in general to enable them be more beneficial to the poor and help improve income distribution.



