Supermarkets rethink self-checkout as customers push for traditional tills

After years of promoting self-checkout, several UK supermarkets are reconsidering their approach and shifting back to traditional staffed tills. Asda has announced plans to increase the number of staff-operated checkouts, while Morrisons has acknowledged that it might have “gone too far” with self-service options. Meanwhile, Northern upmarket chain Booths has eliminated self-scan tills altogether.
The move comes in response to customer frustrations, including the infamous “unexpected item in the bagging area” alert, which has become a common complaint. Despite this, some shoppers remain in favor of self-checkout, preferring the speed and efficiency it offers.
The debate over self-checkout versus staffed tills has intensified as self-scan machines have proliferated over the past two decades, with around 80,000 now in use across the UK. Morrisons’ CEO, Rami Baitiéh, recently admitted that the chain may have overextended its reliance on self-checkouts. “While they drive some productivity, many shoppers, especially those with full trolleys, dislike using them,” he told the Telegraph. As a result, Morrisons is now “reviewing” its use of self-service checkouts and plans to reintroduce more staffed tills.
Asda, facing similar concerns, has also pledged to increase the number of checkout staff after recognizing the limitations of self-service tills. Booths has taken the most drastic step by completely removing self-checkouts from its stores last November.
For some shoppers, the presence of cameras on self-scan tills, which capture live footage of users, has become an additional deterrent. Beverley Hyrb, a 62-year-old from Oldham, Greater Manchester, expressed her discomfort with the surveillance. “You see an image of yourself moving about, and I don’t like it,” she said. “I’d rather get in a queue.” The technology is likely intended to discourage shoplifting, which has surged in England and Wales to its highest level in 20 years as of April.
Ms. Hyrb also noted the mental health benefits of interacting with a cashier during grocery shopping, especially for those who live alone. “It’s just good to chat, whether it’s about the weather or the news,” she said.
For others, self-checkouts present practical challenges. Anna Kenyon from Manchester, who is deaf, struggles with the machines because she cannot hear the beeps when scanning items. “People, as opposed to machines, are much better at adapting to my condition,” she explained, adding that she has had positive experiences with cashiers who spontaneously started signing with her.
However, not everyone shares these concerns. Julie Yates, whose two adult sons have autism, appreciates the independence that self-checkouts provide. “They don’t have to interact with anyone, make eye contact, or engage in small talk,” she said. For her, self-checkouts offer a convenient and stress-free shopping experience.
Others, like 74-year-old Trevor Springford from Dunbar, East Lothian, prefer self-checkouts for their speed. “It’s all about getting in and out fast without having to queue or get involved in a conversation,” he said.
While self-checkouts are unlikely to disappear entirely, the shift back to staffed tills may bring some relief to those who find the machines frustrating. The British Retail Consortium, which represents most of the UK’s major supermarkets, declined to comment on whether this marks the beginning of a broader phase-out of self-scan tills. A spokesperson noted that retailers would adapt checkout systems to meet the diverse needs of their customers.
Ged Futter, director of supermarket consultancy The Retail Mind, emphasized that customer feedback is crucial in shaping these decisions. “At the moment, I think it’s particular to those two retailers [Asda and Morrisons],” he said, adding that while self-scans reduce staff costs, they can backfire if they negatively impact customer experience. “Successful retailing is all about understanding your customer,” he concluded
Fruitful, dynamic cooperation with China promotes Africa’s development
As leaders from China and African nations are scheduled to gather in Beijing for a summit in early September, expectations are high that the event will chart the course for enhancing bilateral cooperation and advancing Africa’s independent and sustainable development.
Through joint efforts under the framework of the Forum on China-Africa Cooperation (FOCAC) as well as the Belt and Road Initiative, continuous and solid progress has been made in cooperation in such fields as industry, agriculture and health, epitomizing the unique resilience and dynamism of China-Africa relations. Such cooperation has helped improve the well-being of the people and promote the industrialization of the continent that is home to the world’s largest number of developing countries.
Recent data highlight the vigorous momentum of China-Africa relations. China has been Africa’s largest trading partner for 15 consecutive years, with bilateral trade reaching a record 282.1 billion U.S. dollars last year. African exports of agricultural products to China have increased for seven straight years. In the first half of this year alone, China imported goods worth 60.1 billion dollars from Africa, up 14 percent year on year.
China is one of the major sources of foreign investment in Africa. By the end of 2023, China’s stock of direct investment in Africa had exceeded 40 billion U.S. dollars. Chinese companies have created 1.1 million jobs in Africa over the past three years, according to the Ministry of Commerce.
China has also promoted the development and transformation of Africa’s industrial chains through capacity cooperation, technology transfer and talent cultivation. China has trained more than 220,000 personnel of various types for African countries, taking into account their actual needs. This also enhances African countries’ capacity for independent development.
Furthermore, China-Africa agricultural cooperation has flourished, producing fruitful results in terms of technical assistance and training of agricultural experts, transfer of advanced agricultural technologies, and the building of agricultural parks, thereby helping modernize agriculture in Africa.
Chinese hybrid rice technology, for example, has assisted countries such as Madagascar and Liberia in increasing their rice output. China’s Juncao, also known as “magic grass,” has been successfully planted and promoted in countries including the Central African Republic, Rwanda and South Africa, increasing the income of local people and contributing to their green development.
China advocates for win-win cooperation, striving to integrate its own development with that of Africa and align the interests of the Chinese and African peoples. Relying on its strengths in industry, investment and infrastructure construction as the world’s second-largest economy, China has cooperated with a number of African countries to build railways, ports, roads, industrial zones and energy projects, driving the industrialization of the continent.
Developing solidarity and cooperation with African countries has been the cornerstone of China’s foreign policy. The phrase “a friend in need is a friend indeed” aptly describes China-Africa cooperation, as it is a partnership founded on mutual respect and support, targeting shared development and win-win outcomes and creating tangible benefits for people in China and Africa. With its solid foundation of unbreakable friendship, China-Africa cooperation will surely reach new heights in the course of building a high-level community with a shared future. Through such cooperation, African countries will secure even greater progress in their independent and sustainable development.



